Actually I deleted everything from my .htaccsess, but this is what was in it.
AuthUserFile "/home/user/.htpasswds/public_html/domain/passwd"
AuthType Basic
AuthName "Restricted Area Due To Construction!!!!"
require valid-user
Like I said I unchecked the box, deleted all active users and the lock Icon next to public_html is gone, but yet it still asks for it. All the old user names and passwords still work so it is still accessible....Just not to the public as I would like it to be.
And Yes I cleared my cache, cookies from browser also........
Go into cPanel file manager > .htpasswds > public_html and see if the "domain.com" folder is there. If so, see what's in it. You may need to delete something there. You can also try enabling, and disabling again. If all else fails, contact support.
What is the domain in question also? If you don't want to share that's fine, but it would help to test different things.